September 4, 2014

A Few Thoughts for Consideration in the Modern Republication Debate

By In Blogs, Brandon Adams

Posted at Particular Voices:

These thoughts are directed primarily at members in the OPC and PCA.

For those contra republication:

    1. The view that the Mosaic covenant was a covenant of works is a view found among Reformed divines in the 17th and 16th centuries.
    2. The Westminster Confession of Faith is not the exclusive expression or boundary of Reformed orthodoxy.

For those pro republication:

    1. The fact that a given divine at the Westminster Assembly held to a given view does not mean that the Confession itself either reflects, includes, or accounts for their view. They debated many things. The conclusion of the debates was a majority vote in one direction, not a unanimous vote.
    2. A covenant of works and a covenant of grace are as different as wood and stone. They are different “substances.” If the Mosaic covenant is a formal covenant of works (not just containing a remembrance of Adam’s covenant) it cannot be…

Continue Reading

Written by Brandon Adams

Husband, Father, Son, Saint, Sinner http://contrast2.wordpress.com